Buy Equipment, Add Overtime or Recover Capacity? A Capital Request Worksheet

A manufacturing capital request worksheet should show how the business can meet a defined output requirement by its deadline. Define accepted output and demand first. Then check whether recovery, overtime, equipment redeployment or purchase can deliver it through every required production and release step. Compare feasible options over one cost horizon, including implementation, labor and qualification.
The question is which option serves the requirement at an acceptable cost and risk. A new machine can be the right answer. So can a smaller process change or a temporary overtime bridge, when the operating evidence supports it.
Cantex was managing recurring hopper cracks and blocked material flow with time-consuming workarounds. In Guidewheel’s case study, the team used downtime, maintenance and scrap data to show why replacing the hoppers could deliver a positive return. The evidence helped explain the opportunity and expected payback to colleagues. The case supports a specific investment rationale; it does not publish a cost or payback figure to reuse.
| Approval test | Required answer |
|---|---|
| Qualified demand | Accepted units, product mix and delivery pattern |
| Feasibility | Proven capacity at the full required process boundary |
| Timing | Implementation and qualification complete before demand arrives |
| Comparable economics | Relevant cash flows over the same horizon |
| Downside plan | Trigger, owner and available fallback |
Define the output requirement before choosing an asset
Write the requirement as accepted output delivered when the customer needs it. A proposed machine rate is an input to feasibility, not the requirement itself.
State the product specification, quantity, demand pattern, deadline and planning horizon. Identify any qualification, inspection or customer approval that must occur before output can ship. Distinguish committed orders from a forecast and explain which demand scenario the request serves.
A request for 24,000 additional units over a year is incomplete if the units must arrive at 2,000 per month starting next month. An option that produces everything at year-end fails that requirement even if its annual total is sufficient.
Check the full route. For a fictional component order, open casting hours count only if finishing, assembly and inspection can complete the same order by its deadline. Record capacity at each required step and accepted output at the final boundary. Moving unfinished units into a buffer does not establish delivery capacity.
Use the route and operating conditions that fit the product. For a batch-chemical request, check the approved recipe and batch cycle. For a continuous-profile request, check qualified tooling and the output rate. Keep different process families separate when checking available hours. Shared material or a common plant owner does not establish that one route can substitute for another.
Use the existing production-capacity guide for the underlying capacity concepts. The capital request begins after that work, with an agreed requirement and evidence about the current constraint.
For each alternative, specify what remains the same and what changes. Does overtime add a qualified crew? Does redeployment displace another order? Does a process improvement require engineering or quality approval? Does a purchase need building work, utilities or additional inspection equipment?
Include demand ownership. The commercial or planning owner should confirm the quantity and delivery assumptions, while quality confirms what counts as accepted output. Without those sign-offs, operations may solve a capacity problem that does not match the actual sales requirement.
Test whether each alternative can meet the deadline
Apply the same feasibility test to every option. Recovering capacity should face the same output and qualification requirement as purchasing equipment.
For a process improvement, show a bounded trial demonstrating useful capacity under representative jobs and staffing. Explain which loss changes and whether the result persists through downstream operations and quality release. State how much of the accepted-output gap the trial closes and what remains uncovered. A theoretical OEE increase is not enough to commit customer deliveries.
For overtime, verify that staffing, materials, support and downstream capacity are available during the extra hours. Use accepted output per additional hour, including expected losses. Avoid assuming a normal-shift rate transfers unchanged to every overtime period.
For redeployment, check the asset's compatibility, condition, transfer work and qualification date. Identify the source plant's displaced production, transport cost and any replacement work. An idle asset may be available, but that does not prove it can make the required product on time.
For purchase, use the supplier's delivery and commissioning plan plus your own site-readiness and qualification requirements. Name the owner of each dependency. A purchase order date and a production-ready date are different milestones.
Consider an illustrative requirement: 2,000 additional accepted units per month, starting next month, for 12 months. Validated incremental capacity is 100 accepted units per hour. Each feasible option therefore needs 20 additional useful hours per month.
| Alternative | Feasibility assumption in the illustration |
|---|---|
| Recover capacity | Trial supports at least 20 additional useful hours monthly |
| Add overtime | Qualified staffing supports 20 hours monthly |
| Redeploy equipment | Transfer and product approval complete before next month |
| Buy equipment | Delivery and qualification miss the next-month start |
The purchase is infeasible as a standalone solution to this requirement. It may re-enter as part of a combined bridge-and-purchase plan, but that combination needs its own complete cost and timing record. Do not award an infeasible option first place because its eventual running cost looks attractive.
Compare relevant costs over one horizon
Compare the costs that change because of each option. Keep unchanged allocations out of the incremental cash comparison, and display timing explicitly.
ACCA's relevant-cost guidance distinguishes decision-dependent cash flows from sunk costs and unchanged allocations. Apply that basis consistently across alternatives rather than giving one option a full cost and another only its labor premium.
The following costs are invented illustrative assumptions, not supplier quotes or Guidewheel pricing. The cost screen uses the same volume of 24,000 accepted units over 12 months; the purchase row is a reference case because it misses the required start date. Common variable conversion cost is assumed to be $2 per accepted unit, or $48,000, for all options. That assumption must be verified in a real request.
| Alternative | Changed option cost over 12 months | Common variable cost | Total cash outflow |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recover capacity | $12,000 implementation + 12 × $500 support = $18,000 | $48,000 | $66,000 |
| Add overtime | 20 hours × 12 months × $70 incremental cost/hour = $16,800 | $48,000 | $64,800 |
| Redeploy equipment | $6,000 transfer/qualification + 12 × $400 support = $10,800 | $48,000 | $58,800 |
| Buy equipment | $80,000 installed + $3,000 qualification + 12 × $1,000 added running/support = $95,000 | $48,000 | $143,000 |
The $70 overtime rate includes all additional employment costs in this illustration. The common $2 conversion cost excludes that overtime cost. If your conversion basis already includes the added labor, remove the overlap. Similarly, include forgone net cash from displaced orders in redeployment costs when moving the asset prevents other profitable work. Deduct only source-site costs that would actually be avoided.
The purchase remains infeasible for the original deadline, so its economics are reference information, not a current approval recommendation. Suppose the analysis also assumes a $40,000 resale at the end of year one. Its option cost net of that assumed sale would be $55,000. Show this separately from the $95,000 cash outflow before disposal. An asset retained in use does not produce that assumed sale receipt.
A short cash-flow screen does not replace a longer capital analysis. If the machine supports later demand, compare alternatives over that agreed longer horizon, with timing, working capital, residual value, replacement needs and the finance-approved discount basis. Keep tax treatment and funding terms consistent.
This illustration is an undiscounted, pre-tax project cash screen; it excludes financing flows. Depreciation is not cash. For discounted project appraisal, avoid adding interest already reflected in the discount rate. Show debt drawdowns and repayments in a separate funding schedule, rather than charging the asset price and loan principal twice.
In the illustration, redeployment has the lowest feasible cash cost only if it displaces no other needed production and passes qualification on time. If either assumption fails, the apparent cost advantage may disappear. Write those conditions beside the recommendation.
Stress-test demand, capacity and the fallback
Test the assumptions most likely to change the decision. A request should show when the recommendation stops meeting demand, not just a favorable base case.
In the illustration, increasing monthly demand from 2,000 to 3,000 accepted units raises required incremental time from 20 to 30 hours at 100 accepted units per hour. Suppose the recovery trial demonstrated a ceiling of 25 extra hours, while approved overtime can support 35. Recovery alone now fails the higher-demand requirement. Overtime remains feasible within its approved scope.
This is a capacity threshold, not a reason to assume more hours can always be recovered. A larger improvement proposal needs its own test and cost. Likewise, overtime beyond the approved limit needs staffing and support confirmation before entering the worksheet.
Test a commissioning delay separately. If redeployment misses the start date, specify the temporary option that covers the shortfall. Calculate its full incremental cost and confirm it is available when needed. An unnamed fallback is not evidence of delivery resilience.
Include a lower-demand case. If forecast orders do not arrive, fixed implementation or purchase spending may remain while unused capacity grows. Compare that outcome with an option whose spending adjusts with actual demand. Do not count future contribution unless the sales case supports it.
Record each sensitivity and the calculation it changes:
| Changed assumption | What to recalculate |
|---|---|
| More accepted units required | Useful hours and every downstream limit |
| Lower accepted rate | Staffing hours, cost and completion dates |
| Qualification delayed | Bridge output, bridge cost and missed-delivery exposure |
| Redeployed asset needed elsewhere | Displaced contribution and source-site fallback |
| Demand falls | Committed spending and remaining utilization |
Set a trigger for escalation, such as forecast demand exceeding tested capacity or a missed qualification milestone. Name the person who will decide whether to switch plans. The fallback should be a feasible option with evidence and cost, ready before the trigger arrives.
Put the approval decision on one page
Give the approver a clear recommendation with its conditions, alternatives and evidence. Keep the supporting records available, but make the decision legible without a long presentation.
A completed request should state the demand, horizon, accepted-output definition and required first-delivery date. Then show feasible alternatives on the same basis. Separate sunk spending, recurring costs, one-time costs and assumed terminal receipts.
For the illustrative base case, the decision record could say: redeploy the qualified asset for the 24,000-unit requirement, conditional on timely transfer and no displaced orders. Use approved overtime if qualification slips. Reconsider the longer-term equipment plan when demand exceeds demonstrated capacity.
That wording explains why the cheapest feasible option was selected and the point where the decision changes. It does not claim redeployment is inherently better than purchase.
| Approval field | What the record contains |
|---|---|
| Requirement owner | Confirmed demand and delivery pattern |
| Operations evidence | Qualified accepted rate and supporting constraints |
| Quality decision | Product approval and release requirements |
| Preferred option | Cost basis, assumptions and implementation owner |
| Rejected options | Specific feasibility or economic reason |
| Sensitivity | Demand and delay thresholds that change the answer |
| Fallback | Confirmed bridge capacity and cost |
| Finance approval | Accepted horizon, cash-flow basis and conditions |
| Recheck | Date or trigger for revisiting the request |
After implementation, compare the actual output, cost and timing with the approved case. Preserve the initial assumptions and explain deviations. That review improves the next capital request and distinguishes a sound decision under uncertainty from an outcome caused by an unanticipated change.
Use the hidden-capacity article when an alternative needs deeper capacity investigation. Keep this worksheet focused on approving a concrete response to qualified demand.
Use measured losses to support a specific capital decision
Bring operating evidence to the investment decision, whether the answer is improvement or replacement.
Guidewheel is the practical operating platform for manufacturing, with software and manufacturing experts helping teams use machine information. Optional system context can support the scoped evaluation. Your finance, quality and operations owners still approve the demand, costs and qualification conditions.
Discuss the evidence behind your capacity decision with Guidewheel.
Frequently asked questions
Should improvement always come before equipment purchase?
No. Evaluate an improvement when it can plausibly meet the requirement, but test its output and timing. Purchase may be the appropriate choice for product capability, sustained demand or a constraint that feasible improvements cannot resolve.
Why exclude an option with the lowest unit cost?
An option that misses the required deadline or quality standard cannot serve the same requirement. Compare costs after feasibility, or build a complete combined option that includes the bridge needed to close its gap.
How should equipment residual value be shown?
Separate cash spending from an assumed terminal value. State whether the asset will actually be sold, retained or transferred, and show the valuation basis. Use the same horizon and finance-approved treatment for every alternative.
Can overtime bridge a delayed equipment purchase?
Yes, when qualified staffing, materials and supporting capacity are available. Treat overtime plus purchase as one combined alternative, with bridge duration, total incremental cost and a fallback if commissioning takes longer.
What evidence should accompany the capital request?
Include confirmed demand, accepted-output requirements, observed capacity, qualification dates, relevant cash flows and sensitivity results. Name the input owners and the conditions that would reopen the approval.